Showing posts with label Pain. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Pain. Show all posts

Tuesday, July 9, 2024

Av

"Woe unto the heart that is not broken,” wrote Aryeh Cohen. 

No one wants pain but no one can avoid it.   

People let us down.  

Our bodies are instruments where the parts wear out and sometimes are defective.  

The things that we expect to make our lives simpler often do the opposite.  

When life does not cooperate with our expectations it is frustrating, to say the least.

 

As we pass through time we amass a wide array of these broken experiences.  Learning how to manage life’s disappointments is wisdom.   Wisdom does not come from books or what others teach us, it what we learn as the wheel of life turns.

 

This month on August 13 is Tisha B’Av, on the Jewish calendar.  Tisha B’Av is a day of historic tragedy.  It marks when our ancestors the Children of Israel, were sentenced o forty years of aimless wandering in the desert. It is the day that marks the destruction of the both the first and second Temples in Jerusalem.  It is also the anniversary of when Betar, the last breath of Jewish independence for 2,000 years fell.  Jews all over the worlds read Jeremiah’s Lamentations and fast.

 

Why?  Why bother to remember an historic event that has no bearing on our life?

 

A story:

 

One Tisha B’Av Napoleon rode by a synagogue in small town and noticed Jews sitting on the ground and wailing bitterly.

“Why are the Jews crying?” he asked a bystander.

“They are mourning their land which was destroyed about two thousand years ago,” he was informed.

These words deeply impressed Napoleon.  “A nation that can mourn over the destruction and loss of their land which occurred two thousand years ago,” he exclaimed, “Such a people will never perish.  They may be certain they will survive and that their land will eventually be restored to them.”

 

Our memory - both individual and collective – takes our pain and uses it to become wiser in our years.  Just as a scab started out as a bleed, it becomes much more resilient when new skin forms over it.  But, and this is crucial, a scar remains to remind us and teach us how to enrich our lives through the panoply of our experiences, good and bad.

Monday, April 29, 2024

Thoughts are Real

 Why does the Torah tell us that after giving birth, a mother must bring a sin offering?

Rabbi Simon bar Yohai answers, "Since she may have cried out in the midst of her birthing pains, "I will never again let my husband come near me."
For such a thought, the Torah requires that a sin offering be brought.
Two ideas emerge from this passage. The first is that people are prone to say regrettable things. We will cry out in the depth or pain despair uttering curses or vows that, given a moment of rational thought, we would never say. The second notion is that even though all humanity may succumb to such wrong and excessive language; we are not excused from what comes from our mouths. We are always held responsible for what we say.
 
The Mishna in Pirkay Avot states, “Know what is above from you. An eye that sees, an ear that hears, and all of your deeds are recorded in a book! (2:1)

Monday, April 8, 2024

The Broken Heart

Just having learned of President John Kennedy’s assassination, Daniel Patrick Moynihan exclaimed, "When you’re Irish, one of the first things you learn is that sooner or later the world will break your heart."

Coping with pain is the great trial we confront time and again. It is no simple matter to deal with the pains of life an adult, well-adjusted manner. We want to scream, curse, cry, or ball up into a tight cocoon where no one can touch us. The older we get the more the same patterns of behavior repeat themselves in our lives. We do the same thing over and over. The source and kind of pain changes but not our reaction to it. 

There is a discussion among the sages in the Talmud about right and wrong blessings. In the midst of one long conversation a rabbi comments that it would be a sin to approach your home, see smoke rising in the distance and pray, "I hope that is not my home." Such a prayer implicitly asks that it be someone else’s home.

A minister was giving an impassioned sermon to his congregation and said, "Everyone in this church is going to die."

The preacher then noticed a man in the front row who was smiling broadly. "Why are you so happy?" the minister asked. 

"I’m not from here. I am just visiting my brother for a couple of days."

We know what pain is like. We are familiar with its taste, texture, how we react to it. For most of us, we are far too intimate with the way it feels. We all know that Moynihan was correct: the world will and does break our heart.

A strong Jewish current of thought is that we are supposed be familiar with a broken heart. That kind of woundedness gives us empathy for others who suffer. It makes us better friends and spouses, better parents and leaders. Above all, it makes us better Jews. Our job is to help people, not be personal consumers for our own welfare. That is why it is a sin to be unconcerned with those who suffer - whether we know them or not.

In the aftermath of the Great Liberation from slavery the Jews threw themselves on the shore of the Sea as the waters rushed to engulf the Egyptians coming to capture them. As the languid waters suddenly gushed over the helpless bodies of the slave-masters, hosts of Angels began to sing in heaven. Praising God’s might and sovereignty they cascaded into a massive chorus of praise. "Stop," said the Holy One. "My children are downing and you sing?" 

Shir HaShirim Rabah 5


Thursday, August 17, 2023

Return

 We chose pain.

If there is a single moral to the tale of Creation it is that Adam HaRishon (primordial man) elected to take the path of pain instead of spending his days on utter comfort.  The Garden was perfect.  There were no needs or wants.  They did not have to work and the possibility of failure did not exist.  There could be no failure.  Likewise there was nothing to succeed at.  All Adam HaRishon had to do was breathe.  
In the taking the forbidden fruit shame launched itself in the consciousness of the two beings.  First naked and unashamed (2:25) Adam and Havvah felt their vulnerability grow into an unrelenting self-conscious throb.  Now, instead of roaming about the Garden Adam and Havvah now crouched in the bushes.  Just moments before the universe stretched before them.  Now, the world had closed in on them.  The skies felt like they were crushing down upon them.  
Self-loathing and fear gripped Adam and Havvah.  Dark suspicions colored the previously pristine Garden.  They accused one another, contemptuously.  He said, “The woman that You gave me—she gave the fruit…” The woman said, “The serpent…”  Perfection was blemished.  Shunned from Eden, Adam and Havvah now had to deal with unimagined pains that would assault their physical being and relentlessly pursue their consciousness.  They crouched lower into the foliage, terrified of the inner darkness.  
Why did they choose the path of pain?
On Hanukka we celebrate in many ways.  Among the more opaque observances is the tradition of spinning the dreidle. B'nei Yissachar said that the difference between Hanukka and Purim is best demonstrated by the dreidle and the gragger.  The dreidle is spun by taking hold of the top and twisting one’s wrist.  The gragger is sounded by taking hold of the bottom and yanking it around.  One is gripped from below; the other above.  That reminds us of the difference between the two holidays.  While Purim celebrates Esther’s ability to find her self and God and save the Jews (below); Hanukka recalls God’s intervention in coming to the aid of the Hasmonean warriors (above) with the miracle of the oil.  
Redemption has different origins in the two holidays.   There are times when we depend upon God and other times when we must depend upon ourselves.  Yet, the connection between Purim and Hanukka is that redemption only comes about through struggle, pain.  Both tales are pock-marked with rivalry, desperation and fear.
It would be nice if life was different…and it was for a brief flicker of time in our past.  We return to our first question: why did they do it?  Why did the sole inhabitants of Eden forfeit perfection?   Why could they not turn their backs from the Tree of Knowledge and forever walk in the Divine Radiance?
The searing question of pain is compounded in this week’s parasha as Jacob’s family descends into the grasp of Egypt.  At first it is a most that benefits everybody.  Prosperity swiftly turns to anguish as Jacob’s children becomes slaves to their present-day neighbors.  Why such pain?  Why must generation after generation endure agony?
In connection with the Torah reading, the Midrash offers:  A farmer needed to yoke his cow.  The cow had no desire to have the wooden plank placed and tightened around her shoulders so she balked. Turning her neck this way and that the farmer could not put the yoke on the animal.  So what did he do? 
The farmer went to the shed and led her calf out in front of the mother.  Pathetically bleating the calf caused the cow to lurch protectively forward. Because of her child the cow allowed herself to become yolked.
It was foreseen that Jacob would have to migrate to Egypt (15:13) long ago.  It was part of the pact that God made with Father Abraham.  There were countless ways to facilitate Abraham’s descendent leaving Canaan for Egypt but God decided to bring the calf first to induce the mother.  The Holy One declared: "He is My firstborn.  Shall I then bring him down to Egypt in disgrace?    I will draw his son before him, and so he will follow despite himself.”  Jacob was forced to go down to Egypt.
So God wants us to suffer?  He ordained the slavery?

Rabbi Shimon bar Yochai said: The Holy One, Blessed is He, gave three good gifts to the Jewish people, and all are acquired through suffering: Torah, the Landof Israel, and the World to Come. (Brachot 5a)

Chassidic teaching explains that two counter-objectives had to be achieved. On the one hand, Jacob had to be compelled to relocate to Egypt -- a voluntary migration would not have been an exile! Galut, by definition, is a place where one does not want to be -- a place that is contrary to one's intrinsic self and will. On the other hand, the fact that Jacob arrived in Egypt in honor, glory and in a position of power as the father of that country's ruler, rather than as a prisoner in chains, meant that he and his descendents would never truly be subject to their host country. Thus the key to Israel's eventual liberation from Egypt was already "programmed" into the circumstances under which their galut 

Rabbi Shimon bar Yochai [the author of the "Zohar"] taught: "Come and see how beloved is Israel to the Holy One, the Source of all blessing. Wherever Israel went into exile, the Shechina went along into exile. They went to exile to Egypt, the Shechina went with them as it is written, Did I not appear to your ancestor's family when they were in Egypt [enslaved] to the house of Pharaoh (Samuel 1:2-27. They went to Babylon in exile and the Shechina went with them, as it is written, because of you I was sent to Babylon (Isaiah 43:14). And when they will eventually be redeemed, the Shechina will be redeemed along with them, as it is written, Then the Lord your God will bring back your captivity and have mercy upon you (Deut. 30:3). The verb used in the verse is not veheshiv, the proper grammatical way to express bringing back someone else in Hebrew, but veshov which expresses the idea of returning oneself; to teach you that God Himself returns along with Israel from its exiles. (Talmud, Megilah, 29a)

 

Thursday, March 25, 2021

The End

One of my teachers in London used to tell the story of a man who jumped into the Mersey River in order to drown himself.  As he jumped into the waters he shouted, “Don’t try to save me!”

A second man came along, plopped into the river screaming, “Nobody try to save me!”

Along came a third man and stood by the water as bystanders watched the unfolding scene.  They yelled at him, “Don’t do it!”

He turned to them and replied, “I am not. I just want to know where they work.”

 

We all attempt to avoid pain; some by jumping into dark waters and others by watching and learning from their experience.   Yet pain is a great teacher, if we choose to view it that way.  It imparts lessons that we would otherwise never learn because we get stuck in the old ways we are used to doing things.

 

Pesach is one of those attempts at learning from past pain.  We experienced slavery and replay that event each year on the anniversary of our liberation.  Yes, we observe the festival to appreciate God’s saving power and His endless patience.  Yes, we go through the rituals yearly as our ancestors did for centuries, millennia, in order to spiritually connect with them.  And, yes, we observe the holy days as a reminder that our task is to bring justice to the world, especially to the needy and persecuted.

 

But Pesach is also about learning the lessons that only pain can teach.  We may choose to avoid those lessons but sooner or later they will catch up with us.  We can run and hide but not forever, from ourselves, or God.  That is why we read Jonah’s story each year on Yom Kippur; in order to be reminded that it is time to stop running from ourselves.

 

We have been through a long dark year of suffering.  The separation, fear of an invisible enemy, the ever-changing rules of distancing, masking and protective measures have left us drained.  We are nearing the edge of the long tunnel and light is beginning to appear.  The question that Pesach asks is the same one we ought to be asking ourselves now. What have we learned from this pandemic?  How have we changed?  Have the conflicts we have witnessed in the world hardened our hearts, like Pharaoh’s when confronted by a threat?  Ask yourself: Have you lost friends, become bitter toward people unlike yourself, paranoid that unknown powerful actors are threatening your existence or controlling your life?  Or has the danger made us more mindful of the need for love, forgiveness and understanding?

 

We are all changed because of the pandemic.  The most important question is how we have changed.  Are we better, more compassionate people?

 

Ever evolving, we readjust our understanding of the world and ourselves all the time.  Thank God for the corona virus.  I am not dismissing or minimizing the pain and deaths so many people throughout the world have endured.  Their pain was real and for many will never entirely disappear.  There are so many broken hearts among us.  Still, I write thank God for what was.  Why?  This painful year has given us an opportunity to rethink and realign our beliefs and practices.  It has pushed us to the limits of what we thought we could not endure and have emerged on the other side of this with a greater sense of what is possible.

 

Robert Fulgham wrote, “…no matter how old you are – when you go out into the world, it is best to hold hands and stick together.”  I see the little children in the school in a long line holding hands daily and it brightens my heart.  A long period of separation is coming to an end and we can now appreciate the simple joys of life in being together again.

 

I pray that we will take time to pause and reflect on what we have, or could have, learned.  God inheres in every moment, in what we perceive as joyful and painful.  What is the take-away lesson we bring with us into our new future?

 

“Tears may linger for a night;

joy comes with the dawn.”  -Psalm 30

 

It is dawn with all its portent for new beginnings.

 

 

Tuesday, December 19, 2017

Broyges

Broyges

Broyges can be a throttling, unsettling kind of silence in an atmosphere so thick it seems impenetrable.  Broyges can also be an argument that blows up and out of control throwing those nearby into a nightmarish frenzy.

Broyges begins with pettiness.

One of my favorite anecdotes is the first time I was called to be a counselor for a floundering marriage. From the time they both awoke in the morning until sleep carried them away in the blackness of night, husband and wife would pick at each other to pieces. Explaining the torment across my office desktop, I asked them to give me an example of how their fights began.

After a pause she blurted out, “He never closes the toothpaste cap!”
I had to keep myself from falling off the chair from laughter. How ridiculous!  And yet how tiny pain grows into mammoth malignancies.

I am familiar with two distinct types of broyges.  One is when is when it concerns family, the other friends.

With family there is no escape. We scream, we yell. We level invectives and charge at our family members with epithets. Some of us become rabbis giving long pious monologues on truth and morality. Others silently sulk through the house with a deep, dark cloud hovering about them.

Who will swallow their pride first? Who will give in and break the impasse?

The one who broods  -- the so-called stronger one -- or the other whose body is laced with fierce indignation while mutely except in the anguish of their spouse or parent?
Either the family will dissolve or someone will attempt reconciliation.  The one who opens the door a crack and allowing for healing at the risk of sacrificing their own pride is the stronger and the bigger of the two.

With friends, estrangement is much more common and difficult. We do not have to see the drooping corners of their mouths at breakfast time.  We do not have to share the same toilet or attend the same parties. “These,” we say, “are not worth the pain or risk to the ego in order to remedy.” So friendships come and they disappear.
Some of is treat family like friends—we alienate and chase them away to the West Coast or to another continent.  Some of us confuse friends with family and fight with them as we would our own blood and then with a full heart make up with them later. Most of us, however, fall in the middle.

And these dark months of winter we have an opportunity to reflect upon our lives and the people around us. Staying indoors against the harsh winds of winter and yet bolstered by the soothing glow a warm home, we have a chance to renew and read discover love. He is a moment to invite a friend over to share the joy of the Hanukkah lights with us.

This is an opportunity to renew the vibrancy of a life that has known too much broyges.



Friday, December 8, 2017

Understanding and Becoming

Understanding is the path to becoming.
For example, when someone is in great pain and you have experienced that same pain, you feel deeply for them. It is called empathy. If you have a broken leg you know how to speak to someone whose had the same misfortune. Understanding how the person feels is living inside of that person, however briefly.   We become them in a sense because we are empathic.
The same is true for everything that looks confusing.  If we have gone through it, travelled the same path, we understand.  If, on the other hand, someone behaves in a manner that appears like nothing we have ever experienced, we do not understand them or what motivates their actions.
 When we try to look at the world and wrestle with the complexities of reality, one thing is most helpful to bear in mind: silence apprehends more than words. We can understand a person better if we just relied upon our senses. Biology would never be necessary if we pay better attention to nature. Mathematics would be redundant in the world we all do their own accounting. The same is true of human nature.  If we take responsibility to listen and try to understand, empathy becomes easier. True, we may never endure what someone else lives through but we can still draw parallels and hope to gain insight and understanding.

While our parents may not beat us we know what is like it is going to suffer.  If we listen with our hearts with our ears, we can understand.  Understanding leads to empathy.  Empathy leads to becoming.

Thursday, July 4, 2013

Kick ‘Em in the Shins




Kick ‘em in the shins is a philosophy of life.
It goes like this: If you kick them in the shins they will stop complaining about their headache.  Now, while I am not suggesting anyone commit any small act of violence, the idea does work.

From a religious point of view it generally works, too.  There are few times when we have great clarity of vision.  Most often our view is obscured by doing the shopping, picking up the kids, picking up after the spouse, preparing dinner, working, servicing the car, mowing the lawn….  

In the midst of all these errands and obligations, we lose sight of the reason are doing them.  Work is for clothes and food and shelter.  The car is to make it possible to work.  Eating is the seminal communal activity that binds the family.   School is to gain basic tools for survival.  

Yet the reality of most people’s lives is that we work to get “more things” and have our self-esteem boosted.  We wear clothes to make statements to others about our prosperity and taste.  We drive non-utilitarian cars to draw attention to our economic status.  We eat because we are hungry and do so swiftly so that we can get to the important tasks of watching our favorite television program or shuttle junior to the game.  Likewise, the premise of school is to have a good Grade Point Average in order to get to the next level: The object is not to learn.

No wonder life is so unsatisfactory.  It bleeds us without allowing for replenishment.  The basic life functions which nourish the soul like eating a leisurely meal and enjoying the family news of the day with one another gives great rewards.  Time spent keeping busy is not synonymous with living.  In fact, most of us are just waiting for life to really begin.  The stuff thus far does not qualify as living….

Still, every now and again comes the vision of how life is really supposed to be.  Not surprisingly, the clarity comes when someone close to us is near death.  With startling lucidity everything makes sense: the car is irrelevant, the electronic toys are meaningless, the unceasing carpools are an utter waste of time.  Time spent holding hands becomes the only currency.  Money saved from years of scrimping are meaningless in the “shadow of death” and the ultimate meaning of life.  Words of love exchanged are gold.  Nothing else matters.  It’s like being kicked in the shins.

Religion is supposed to make us feel more alive.  Think of how often the liturgy reflects nothing more than thanks.  Think of how often the liturgy reflects nothing more than thanks. The ideas are repetitive bordering on banal.  Yet, it’s like being kicked in the shins.