Thursday, October 10, 2013

The Question of Hanukkah


The Ancient Ones of the Talmud ask: Why do we say the beracha (blessing) “…Who has commanded us to light the lamp of Hanukka?”  After all, where does G-d command us to light the Hanukkiah?  Search all you like, it is not possible to find such an ordinance in the pages of the Torah or any other primary Holy Book containing God’s word.  That is because the events of Hanukkah happened after the Tanakh (Bible) was a closed book.

Our tradition teaches the value of a question.  We are told to strive for truth.  We arrive at that place of truth only by turning over very stone in our path.  The incisive and never-ending questions, which the rabbis apply to the universe, are beyond rigorous.  We are told to take nothing for granted.  We will, for example, never accept any person above the borders of accountability.  We will tolerate no Law unless it has been thoroughly tested.  Our instruments of testing?  Questions.

We are known as the people of the question (The Jewish reply to this is, “How do you know?”).  We do not argue for arguments sake but to arrive at the truth.

In Deuteronomy, we read “Ask your father and he will show you; your elders and they will tell you.”  The rabbis instituted the mitzvah of lighting Hanukkah candles some two thousand years after this statement was made.  The rabbis used the verse from the Torah to indicate that they were empowered with the ability to create a tradition and endow it with such sanctity that they could add the blessing “Who has commanded us…” to the act of candle lighting.

Yet, the answer to the original question is inferior to query itself.  The real answer is in the questioning.  We are never permitted to rest from the act of searching for the real answers to life’s challenges.  At times once pat answers will become weakened with age.  Other times it will withstand gale forces.  In fact, one twentieth century Jewish author, L. Stein penned, “The wise man questions the wisdom of others because he questions his own…”

In the Talmud, Shmuel bar Nachman remarked, “One who is not ashamed to ask will in the end be exalted.”  Why?  Because he is one step closer to the truth.

Where does truth reside?  The truth inheres in the question.

The Best


Best advice to couples:
                   “If you wife is short, bend down”---Talmud
 In other words, never be haughty; lovers and companions must be equals.

On Time:
                    There is no greater gift than time; that is why they call it the “Present.”

Best advice to children:
                      Sticks and stones may break my bones,
                      And names will always hurt me.
                      “Life and death are on your tongue”—Talmud

What is Most Important in Life:
                      People can be deprived of food and water; They can be ridiculed and
abused. They can get along with almost any pain. Yet, no one can survive without Love.

On Change:
                      A Master once asked his pupils: What is the difference between east and west?  One answered that it was 4,00 miles. Another shouts that it was
double that 8,00 miles. More and more answers were offered. At each response, the Master shook his head. Finally, he told them, “My students, the difference between East and West is a single step. All you have to do is turn around.”

Best Advice you Ever Receive:
                        “Discretion is the better part of Valor.”

Thursday, September 12, 2013

Worry?


The seventeenth century philosopher, Baruch Spinoza thought of worry is “an inconstant pain” arising from the thought that something bad might happen in the future.  For Spinoza, worry is essentially future oriented.  Even if our focus of worry is about something that happened in the past, it is only in relation to how it will affect our future.  - Rabbi Gregory S. Marx

So what does this mean?  That we spend invaluable, irreplaceable time agonizing over what only  might come to pass?


Sunday, September 8, 2013

A New Year Goes


Julius Lester wrote, “I don’t like it when gentile and Jewish friends greet me at Rosh Hashanah with “Happy New Year.” Rosh Hashanah is not the equivalent of January 1.

“I have never understood what “Happy New Year” is supposed to mean. I’ve never been sure that I want to be wished happiness. I’m not sure I know what happiness is, or that it is as important as we think. Happiness feels better than misery, but some of the most important periods of my life have been the ones of profound unhappiness. For all the feelings of well-being that happiness bestows upon us, it is not the goal of life.”

The holy days are over.  Families gathered and returned back to their homes.  The rushes of gatherings, holiday meals, and good wishes have long receded into thin memories.  We have pleaded for life and forgiveness. We starved ourselves on Yom Kippur as we imagined God surrounded by each soul and myriads of Angels waiting in turn for judgment.  A stay has been granted. 

Sukkot have been put away for another year.  Etrog and lulav are already turning brown.

Now comes the hard part. Longing for real change, it comes upon us in most mundane ways.  Judaism is a religion of faith in action.  Professing our belief in the God of Abraham and the importance of Judaism is nice, but for us God is not in the details; God is in what we do.  

That is why this is the hard part.  The Hebrew month we are in is Heshvan.  In Heshvan there are no holydays: it is empty of the numerous cues reminding us of God and self that dot the calendar for the rest of the year.   To fully realize our Jewish identity we must reach toward the promises we made last month and aspirations we vowed on Kol Nidre and begin to embody them.  This is our time to be tested, our Akeidah of sorts, determining whether the faith God trusted to us when our life was in the balance was well placed.

“After ecstasy, the laundry,” states an ancient wisdom.

Folding the clothes and putting them away we can sing a song to God.  In rising each morning we can say the Sh’ma and praise God for another day.  Instead of throwing papa’s tefillin away we can learn to put them on.  Perhaps mama’s tzedaka box can be retrieved from the cardboard boxes in the attic.  We can remember our parent’s yahrzeit and come to shul to say Kaddish for them this year.  From blessing our children to lighting Shabbat candles this is our time, our test.

Theologian Eugene Borowitz wrote, “No philosophy today empowers and elevates conscience, while economics, sociology, psychology and particularly psychoanalysis make man distrustful of it.”  So what can elevate our sense of wellbeing if not lofty ideas?  Doing the right thing.  Doing the godly thing.  Following and acting on the faith of the ages.  We are what we do.  We are not what we think. 

We have 613 mitzvot.  Pick one, any one, and start there.

Like Julius Lester, I did not wish you a “Happy New Year” on Rosh Hashanah but I did wish you a fulfilling one where you can become God’s vision of you.  My wish for you has not changed.

Some people call Heshvan, Mar-Heshvan, meaning the “bitter” Heshvan because of the lack of holidays.  I think of Heshvan as the month of opportunity.  It is a testing ground to determine whether we have changed or only aged another year.


Monday, September 2, 2013

Blessed are the Different



In olden days (not so very long ago) people who looked significantly different from others were placed in circuses where spectators could ogle and spit with no fear of any wrongdoing.  After all, the bearded lady and tiny prince were on display!  They were on stage, parading about as weird anomalies of nature.
            In yet older times, such individuals were thought to be possessed of demons.  Their parents must have committed some foul crime to give birth to such offspring!  Like the famed hunchback of Notre Dame there was no limit to the cruelties that could be leveled at them.  Human dignity extended only as far as the eye could see.
            Ancient Greeks would place deformed infants on the mountaintops to die of exposure.  The Greek civilization reasoned that they could be of little use to their family and society, if allowed to live.  The Nazis also adopted this notion of utility.  Their logic was that if members of society could not be productive, they would be leeches draining the nation of valuable resources.  Better they should be exterminated.  That is why the Nazis first gassed the mentally impaired- no use wasting energy on a population segment that could not create the nascent Reich.
Wendy Mogul, author of  Blessings of a Skinned Knee: Using Jewish Teachings to Raise Self-Reliant Children describes this scene:
                    When my family and I were studying at a Hebrew language institute in Israel one summer, we were housed at a hotel with a large group of what the Israelis called "special people" (mentally retarded and physically handicapped adults) enjoying their government-sponsored beach holiday. My children had never before seen people as peculiar looking and oddly behaved as these. One had a large knobby growth protruding from her ear, one had legs two inches in diameter, and there was Moti, a friendly young man of very limited intelligence. Moti spent much of his time vigorously greeting every passerby with a hearty "Good Morning!" and a nonstop handshake whatever the hour, day or night.
                     You see, most of the world would rather have sights like this far removed from their vision.  Yet, in Israel, the “special people” are a part of the fabric of everyday life.

A definition.  Normal, n. anyone like me.
                                                                             É
                     From the time we are young we are taught to make distinctions between us and them.  The boys have a contest against the girls.  The teachers vs. students.  The in-crowd vs the geeks.  Us vs. them.  Aryans vs Jews.  Backs vs whites.  Where distinctions become more limited we invent them.  Tutsis vs. Hutus.  Hindus vs Sikhs. 
                     Sometimes we resort to self-definition by what we are not.  That is, we develop an identity by pointing to others and saying “that’s not me.”  I suspect the people that visited the Man with the Elephant Ears went home feeling much better about themselves.  I also suspect that the Nazis felt empowered as they rid themselves of human detritus much in the same way that the Greeks blessed themselves when they produced healthy children.
                     Closest to the truth is that no one fits the mold of “normal.”  No one.  As we are all cast in a unique fashion – everyone is either normal or abnormal.  Take your pick.  “Why did God create all humanity through one human being?” asks the Talmud.  “So that no one can say that their lineage is superior.”  It then goes on to say that, “no two people are exactly alike even though we are all made from the same mold.  Therefore everyone must say The universe was created for my sake.”    Mishna Sanhedrin 4:5


                        There's a Jewish blessing that is said when you see exceptionally beautiful people or things: "Blessed are you, Lord our God, who has such beauty in His universe." And there is one to say when noticing strange-looking people or animals: "Blessed are you, Lord our God, who varies creation."
            Pay close attention: We do not recoil when we see a human being different from the “norm.”  We are not to “count our blessings” either.  Instead, our faith holds that we thank God for having created each person uniquely.  Unlike the Nazis and other societies we do not kill the disabled or gawk at them to appreciate our own bounty; they are to be valued as much as the abled.